A mattress costs a lot to buy and a lot more to replace. One overnight accident, a leaking cup or a pet that climbs on the bed can leave a stain that never fully lifts.
Waterproof mattress covers stop that. But they come in two main forms, and the right one depends on who sleeps on the bed and what the bed is exposed to. This guide compares them, then matches each to kids, potty training, incontinence, pets and rentals. It also covers ratings, noise, certifications, sizing, price and care.
Protector or Encasement: Which Waterproof Mattress Cover Fits
A fitted protector covers the sleep surface and the edges. A full encasement seals every side of the mattress. Exposure decides the fit: the more often liquids, allergens or pests reach the mattress, the more sealing you need.

Waterproof Mattress Protector: Top Surface and Edges
A waterproof mattress protector fits like a fitted sheet. It covers the top and wraps the sides, so spills and accidents stop at the cover instead of soaking the foam or springs. It goes on and comes off in a minute, which matters when you strip a bed at 3 a.m.
SureGuard’s flagship protector is 100% waterproof and hypoallergenic, with a pure cotton top surface, a 10-year warranty and GREENGUARD Gold certification. For a crib, the Crib Size SureGuard Mattress Protector offers protection against liquids, stains and allergens, at around USD 27.97.
A protector does not close the underside of the mattress. If your main worry is bed bugs, it is not the right tool.
Waterproof Mattress Encasement: Sealed on Every Side
A waterproof mattress encasement wraps the whole mattress. The Crib Size SureGuard Mattress Encasement offers 360-degree protection against liquids, stains, allergens and bed bugs. SureGuard positions it for households with pets or children, at around USD 39.97.
Put the two crib products side by side and the trade is clear. They share a bed size, so the gap of around USD 12 buys full coverage instead of top-and-edge coverage. Whether that is worth paying depends on how often your household sees accidents, allergens or pests.
For a longer side-by-side, read protector vs encasement explained.
Waterproof Ratings, Noise and Breathability: What to Expect
Every cover in this category says “waterproof” somewhere on the box. The word means very little until you know what stands behind it, and the same goes for how the cover feels at night.
What a Waterproof Rating Should Tell You
“Waterproof” should mean a tested liquid barrier: a layer that keeps liquid from passing through, not one that slows it down. “Water-resistant” and “stain-resistant” are weaker claims. They suggest a cover that repels a light spill but may let a full accident through to the mattress.
Look for what the maker actually tested before you trust either label. A product page that names the barrier layer and says the whole cover is waterproof tells you more than a badge does.
Not every mattress pad or topper is waterproof, either. Many are quilted comfort layers that soak up liquid like the mattress underneath.
Waterproof but Breathable: Noise and Airflow Trade-offs
The barrier that stops liquid also limits airflow, and some barrier layers crinkle when you move. You will not get a fully waterproof cover that behaves exactly like bare cotton sheeting, so be wary of any promise that it does.
The top fabric does most of the work you feel. A soft cotton surface, like the pure cotton top on SureGuard protectors, sits against your skin and takes the edge off the barrier beneath. Judge any cooling claim by that fabric and the construction, not by the word “cooling” on the packaging.
If you sleep warm or sweat at night, choose a protector over an encasement. A protector leaves the underside of the mattress open to air. An encasement wraps the whole mattress in barrier fabric, so it usually runs warmer.
Choosing a Waterproof Mattress Cover by Use Case
No single best waterproof mattress cover exists. The right choice depends on the sleeper and the risk, so start with who is in the bed and how often something goes wrong.
Kids, Potty Training and New Parents
For a child in a bed, a protector is usually enough to start with. The Smooth Twin Size SureGuard Mattress Protector suits a twin bed, and the Crib Size protector covers a crib mattress. If your child is moving out of a crib, the waterproof twin protector for kids page gives bed-size detail.
Potty training brings a stretch of night accidents. A fitted protector handles most of them, and you can wash it between nights.
Step up to the Crib Size encasement if accidents are frequent or liquid keeps reaching the edges. New parents get the same logic: a leaking diaper is a contained mess on a protector and a sealed one on an encasement.
Incontinence, Pets and Short-Term Rentals
Heavier, repeated exposure calls for sealed coverage. For an adult bed, the Queen (17-20 in. Deep) SureGuard Mattress Encasement provides 360-degree protection against liquids, stains, allergens and bed bugs. That suits an incontinence mattress cover role, a bed a pet shares, or a rental where guests change every few days and you cannot see what happened between stays.
Pets and incontinence share the same problem: liquid finds the seams and edges of an unsealed bed. A mattress protector for pets covers the top, but a pet that digs or sleeps at the edge tests the limits of a fitted cover.
For rental hosts, bed bugs are the other worry. An encasement is a barrier, not a cure. It keeps bugs from reaching the mattress, but it does not treat an infestation already in the room. Read more about bed bug encasements before you rely on one, or see the US EPA’s bed bug guidance.
Size and Depth Guide, Including Crib and Mini Crib
Covers are sized to bed type, so a crib, mini crib or twin cover fits those mattresses and not much else. For larger beds, depth matters as much as width and length.
The Queen Size SureGuard Mattress Encasement comes in 4 depth options: 6 to 8, 9 to 12, 13 to 16, and 17 to 20 inches deep. Measure your mattress depth before you order, and check it against that range. A mattress that is too thick for the cover strains the seams, and one that is too thin leaves slack that bunches.
Waterproof Crib Mattress Protector Fit: Crib and Mini Crib
The SureGuard crib family comes in four protectors:
- Crib Size SureGuard Mattress Protector, around USD 27.97
- Smooth Crib Size SureGuard Mattress Protector, around USD 27.97
- Mini Crib SureGuard Mattress Protector, around USD 25.97
- Smooth Mini Crib SureGuard Mattress Protector, around USD 25.97
Match the name to your mattress: crib for a standard crib, mini crib for a mini crib. A waterproof crib mattress protector must fit snug and tight for infant sleep, because loose fabric is a hazard in a crib. Pull the corners down and smooth the surface flat.
Our mini crib fit guide walks through what a correct fit looks like.
Certifications That Matter: GREENGUARD Gold and Hypoallergenic Claims
GREENGUARD Gold is a third-party certification for low chemical emissions into indoor air. SureGuard attributes it to its entire product range. For a parent buying for a nursery or an adult with sensitive airways, that matters: the cover sits against skin for eight hours a night.
It does not prove the cover is waterproof, and it does not prove it blocks allergens. Those are separate claims that need their own evidence. Treat the certification as one check, not a full verdict.
A hypoallergenic waterproof mattress cover is a sealed barrier plus regular washing, not a label word. The barrier keeps dust mites, pet dander and mold spores from settling into the mattress, and washing clears what collects on the cover itself. The allergy mattress cover guide goes deeper on dust mites and dander.
Price and Value Across Sizes
Prices run from around USD 25.97 for the Mini Crib SureGuard Mattress Protector to around USD 64.97 for the Queen (17-20 in. Deep) SureGuard Mattress Encasement. The Smooth Twin Size protector sits at around USD 33.97. These figures change, so confirm them on each product page.
The lowest sticker price is not automatically the best value. Judge a cover on what the money buys: how much of the mattress it covers, which certifications it carries and what the warranty promises. A cheap cover that leaks at the seam costs more than a sealed one that lasts.
If your bed and household match, go to the product page. The Smooth Twin Size SureGuard Mattress Protector suits a child’s twin bed. The Crib Size SureGuard Mattress Protector suits a crib. The Queen Size SureGuard Mattress Encasement suits an adult bed with pets, incontinence or rental turnover.
Washing and Care That Keep the Waterproof Layer Working
Harsh washing and high-heat drying wear down a waterproof layer over time. The barrier is thin, so heat and chemicals that a cotton sheet shrugs off can break it down. That is why a washable waterproof mattress cover still needs gentle handling.
Follow each product’s care label, because it is the only authority on what that cover tolerates. Skip fabric softener and bleach unless the label allows them. Dry on low heat, or air dry.
Frequently asked questions
What can I use to protect a mattress from pee?
Use a waterproof mattress protector for top-and-edge coverage, or a full encasement if accidents are frequent or you want every side sealed. Check the label for a waterproof claim, not just water-resistant or stain-resistant.
Are all mattress pad covers waterproof?
No. Many mattress pads and toppers are quilted comfort layers that soak up liquid like the mattress beneath. Only a cover described as waterproof, with a barrier layer, will stop an accident reaching the mattress.
Do cooling mattress protectors actually work?
The liquid barrier limits airflow, so any cooling effect comes mostly from the top fabric and the construction. Treat a cooling claim with caution and look at what the surface is made of, such as a pure cotton top.
What is the best mattress protector for someone who sweats?
Choose a protector over a full encasement. A protector leaves the underside of the mattress open to air, while an encasement wraps the whole mattress in barrier fabric and usually runs warmer. A soft cotton top surface also helps.
